2008 Breeders' Cup - Is Santa Anita's Synthetic Track the Real Challenge?

Located a mere 14 miles from downtown Loswith Polytrack (made of crushed rubber, sand, fiber,
Angeles, California, Santa Anita Park is home to theand wax), Cushion Track (also made of a unique blend
2008 Breeders' Cup World Championships. For the firstof sand, synthetics and wax), Safetrack (comprised of
time in the event's history, its main event, the Breeders'synthetic and fiber enhanced materials), Tapeta (made
Cup Classic, will be raced on a synthetic track. Whileof sand, wax and fibers), and Pro-Ride (made of
some trainers approve of the move to an all-weathersimilar materials but is more elastic and adaptable to
main track, there are those who feel the so-calledhotter temperatures) being the more popular synthetic
safety benefits aren't entirely accurate.options.
What do the statistics say?What do the trainers think of synthetic racetracks?
According to horse racing reports released last AprilAlthough all of Fame thoroughbred horse trainer Nick
(gathered by veterinarians from 42 participatingZito admitted to liking synthetic tracks for training
racetracks), the number of injuries leading to deaths onpurposes, he doesn't agree with a nation-wide move
dirt tracks is up (from March), while the number ofto synthetic racetracks.
injuries occurred on synthetic tracks have dropped."I don't want to run on anything made from my attic,"
March dirt injuries leading to fatalities: 244 from 123,890said Zito. "I've been in this game since I was 15. God
thoroughbred starters (or a ratio of 1.96 per 1,000).made dirt and God made grass. I'm very upset about
March synthetic surface injuries leading to deaths: 58this business right now."
from 29,744 thoroughbred starters (or a 1.95 per 1,000Another top trainer, Bob Baffert, shares Zito's opinions
ratio).of the stuff. Baffert says that because the horses
In April that ratio rose to 2.02 fatalities on dirt and 1.47can't dig into the track like they can on dirt, the
on artificial surfaces per 1,000 starters. A morethoroughbred's hind legs may become more
complete and accurate report on death-related injuriessusceptible to injury and as a result he has seen more
occurring in the months since April is not currentlyrear end injuries and soreness. On the other hand, top
available since not all racetracks have agreed toKentucky Derby trainer Eoin Harty (Colonel John's
include their injury reports. A new national racetracktrainer) believes synthetic tracks are a God send and
injury database is in the works, but even that has beena career saver.
hard to piece together."I do know for a fact it keeps them sounder," Harty
Mary Scollay, the Kentucky Horse Racing Commissionsaid. "Your primary obligation as a trainer is to do
equine medical director who heads the injury databasewhat's in the best interest for the owner and the
creation project (along with The Jockey Club), sayshorse. If you can prolong a horse's career, that's going
that the commission should do more to get theto keep him sounder. That's your No. 1 obligation."
participation by all licensed veterinarians in order toStill, the bottom-line belief coming from advocates of
provide a more accurate report.this much-needed surface change believe that
"It is time for us to start being more direct in oursynthetic tracks are easier on horses than
approach in tracking non-racing related injuries," Scollayconventional dirt tracks. They say it's more resilient,
said. "I would like the committee to recommend to thethat the horses bounce over it instead of hitting it with
commission that licensed veterinarians be required toa thud, and that in the end it will reduce injuries and
participate in the database."keep horses running more productively.
The Jockey Club vice president of corporateWith the 2008 Breeders' Cup only a few weeks
communications, Bob Curran, agrees with Scollay andaway, it remains to be seen what Rick Dutrow, the
adds that a further study of both dirt and syntheticoutspoken trainer of Breeders' Cup favorite Big Brown,
track surfaces is essential to the transparency of thethinks of Santa Anita's synthetic track. For now, the
sport.enigmatic trainer maintains he's doing what he can to
Is California ahead of the field?prepare his horse for the race of his life. Since Big
In an effort to increase its racing season and toBrown's Belmont Stakes bomb, the 2008 Kentucky
improve the safety of its thoroughbreds and riders,Derby and 2008 Preakness Stakes winner has gone
California horse racing officials have made syntheticon to win three more races. And what about Big
main tracks a mandate at all racetracks.Brown's big nemesis, Curlin? The champion's owners
Santa Anita's all-weather main track opened forare taking a pass on the 2008 Breeders' Cup Classic
training on September 4, 2007, and for racing at thebecause they are not willing to jeopardize the health of
start of the 39th annual Oak Tree Racing Associationtheir horse just to win against Big Brown on Santa
meet on September 26, 2007. The track is a one mileAnita's synthetic track. This may change as the date
oval with two chutes and measures 1 1/4-mile anddraws near, however.
seven furlongs. The distance from the last turn to finishThe 2008 Breeders' Cup will be televised live on ESPN
line measures 990 feet, with the homestretch widthand ABC on October 24th and 25th. Even if you're not
coming in at 85 feet and the backstretch width at 80planning on placing any bets on the 2008 Breeders'
feet. Other synthetic, all-weather surfaces have beenCup, be sure to tune into this must-see television event.
tested and installed at racetracks around the country,